NEW YORK – The World Jewish Congress (WJC) today released a
new report exposing systemic bias, extremist propaganda, and governance
failures on Arabic-language Wikipedia, raising serious concerns about the
integrity of one of the world’s most widely used sources of information.
The report, “Captured Knowledge: Systematic Bias, Hostile
Actors, and Governance Failures on Arabic Wikipedia,” finds that key
articles related to the Israeli–Palestinian conflict and the October 7, 2023
terrorist attacks repeatedly violate Wikipedia’s core neutrality policies and
rely heavily on sources affiliated with terrorist organizations and propaganda
outlets.
The findings highlight the growing global risks posed when
manipulated information ecosystems feed not only public discourse but also the
artificial intelligence systems that millions of people rely on for
information.
Among the report’s most alarming findings:
- Extensive use of terrorist and propaganda sources: More than 25% of citations in key articles—and over 50% in some cases—originate from Hamas-, Hezbollah-, or other terrorist propaganda platforms.
- Terrorist organizations framed as “resistance movements”: Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad are frequently described as legitimate resistance factions, while attacks on civilians are labeled “martyrdom operations.” Some articles refer to designated terrorists as “martyrs” and celebrate suicide bombings and attacks on civilians as historical “achievements.”
- Systemic governance failures: Influential administrators have publicly rejected Wikipedia’s neutrality principle as a “Western concept,” while editors attempting to introduce neutral language or verified facts have reportedly been blocked or banned.
- Massive downstream impact on global information systems: Wikipedia content is widely used to train AI models and inform search results, meaning biased material can propagate far beyond the platform itself.
“This report demonstrates that one of the world’s most
trusted knowledge platforms is being systematically manipulated to promote
extremist narratives,” said Yfat Barak-Cheney, Executive Director of the World
Jewish Congress’ Institute for Technology and Human Rights (TecHRI).
“When terrorist propaganda and hate-driven narratives are
allowed to masquerade as neutral information, the consequences extend far
beyond Wikipedia itself. These distortions shape public understanding and views
of Jews and Israelis across the Arabic-speaking world.”
The report calls on the Wikimedia Foundation to take urgent
action to restore neutrality and accountability on Arabic Wikipedia, including
enforcing existing neutrality standards, removing administrators who enable
extremist propaganda, and implementing centralized monitoring mechanisms for
terrorism-related content.
It also urges technology companies and search engines to
apply safeguards when relying on Wikipedia content for AI training and
retrieval systems until meaningful reforms are implemented.
“Wikipedia has long presented itself as humanity’s shared
knowledge repository,” Barak-Cheney added. “Ensuring that this knowledge
remains factual is particularly critical as emerging AI platforms increasingly rely
on multilingual information sources to formulate responses to user queries.”
The full report is available here.
La source de cet article se trouve sur ce site
